Infant Circumcision


If circumcision were a choice I had to have made, I would have run frantically from the hospital with my newborn son to protect him from the procedure. His father would have chased me down, insisting his son "look like he did." All I can say is I'm terribly relieved I didn't have to live through that. Nor did I have to make the agonizing choice of protecting my baby from pain or disrespecting my husband. It would have been a huge battle of conscience. I was spared and given daughters.

The decision to circumcise an infant boy or not is, in the USA and I'm assuming, most of the world, still a parent's sole responsibility. More and more doctors and pediatricians are recommending against routine circumcision. The controversy is beginning to reach epidemic proportions and will soon be a major issue facing new parents. I feel very sorry for those parents. They will be bombarded with opinions at every turn and surely go though hell with it, unless they have settled this issue between them before the baby's birth. Hopefully, they will agree. The problem I foresee is the parents not agreeing on circumcision, creating a stressful situation where there should be only joy.

Cultural tradition and religious practices notwithstanding, there is no longer a medical or rational reason to circumcise a child other than for purely "cosmetic" reasons. Circumcision is a very painful procedure, performed on a completely innocent and unsuspecting baby. This procedure rattles me to the point that I have refused to attend the Bris of more than one friend's baby son. (A Bris is a Jewish ceremony whereby a Rabbi circumcises an infant boy ... with a lot of witnesses.) Please understand, I have absolutely nothing against the Jewish faith. I have nothing against any faith, even if I do not agree with their beliefs or practices. I DO, however, have something against anyone who inflicts pain on an innocent child. This would include some cultures that also routinely circumcise adolescent girls. If we agree that this is a barbaric ceremony, can we then apply some of that sensibility to infant boys? Sure, male circumcision does not alter a boy sexually but it does cause considerable pain to our babies without any apparent benefit to the child. The issue of cleanliness is no longer a factor. In modern society, frequent bathing is as common as brushing one's hair.

Routine circumcision is obviously not malicious intent to senselessly cause pain to an infant, however, there is much information available today, most of which supports the case against circumcising. Not at least questioning this practice is burying one's head in the sand no matter how the parents choose to proceed.

Consider the recent poll numbers obtained by American Baby magazine on circumcision:

57% chose to circumcise

42% chose not to

2% were undecided

20% said it was a hard decision to make.

Granted, as life decisions go, circumcision is not one of the most enormous in relation to the impact it will have on our babies. I believe it is more an issue of questioning generally accepted practices that no longer serve logical purposes. As neonatal circumcision is still performed on the majority of boys, (at least in the United States), this controversy should continue for a number of years. It will be interesting to see how our culture progresses and what the poll numbers will be like ten years from now.

Copyright ? 2000-2002- Rexanne Mancini

Rexanne Mancini is the mother of two daughters, Justice and Liberty. She is a novelist, freelance writer and maintains an extensive yet informal parenting and family web site, Rexanne.com ? http://www.rexanne.com -Visit her site for good advice, award-winning Internet holiday pages and some humor to help you cope. Subscribe to her free newsletter, Rexanne's Web Review, for a monthly dose of Rexanne: http://www.rexanne.com/rwr-archives.html







Related News



Kinderhotels offer a special menu for little ones - Easier (press release)

Easier (press release)

Kinderhotels offer a special menu for little ones
Easier (press release), UK -10 hours ago
With a Kinderhotel, travelling with children needn’t be a nightmare, because most baby and toddler equipment is provided free of charge. ...

Calling All Babies and Toddlers: It's Time to Savor the Flavors of ... - Market Wire (press release)

Calling All Babies and Toddlers: It's Time to Savor the Flavors of ...
Market Wire (press release) -8 hours ago
... pomme bébé's summer menu creates yet another opportunity for busy families to build strong minds and bodies with 100% organic baby and toddler meals. ...

Your Toddler Might Need a Cholesterol Test - U.S. News & World Report

Your Toddler Might Need a Cholesterol Test
U.S. News & World Report, DC -Jul 7, 2008
In the past, docs worried that babies wouldn't get enough fat, which is critical for brain development, if they didn't drink whole milk. ...

How to spend more time with the children - guardian.co.uk

How to spend more time with the children
guardian.co.uk, UK -18 hours ago
After spotting an advert in a trade publication, she bought a franchise of Musical Minis - which provides music classes for babies and toddlers - and has ...

NBC urged to cancel 'Baby Borrowers' due to health, safety concerns - Reality TV World

NBC urged to cancel 'Baby Borrowers' due to health, safety concerns
Reality TV World, MA -Jul 7, 2008
"Separating babies and toddlers from their parents for extended periods of time can lead children to feel distress and anxiety," the organization wrote in ...

The Positive Power of "No" - KREN CW 27 TV

The Positive Power of "No"
KREN CW 27 TV, NV -Jul 7, 2008
As babies, children raised in a supportive home are the center of the universe. Everything is done for them. In their toddler years, children begin to ...

Welcome to Nashville, Sunday Rose! - My Tennessean.com

Welcome to Nashville, Sunday Rose!
My Tennessean.com, TN -5 hours ago
“Also, the best trick out there that worked wonders with my daughter and all my friends babies is a Fisher Price Infant Toddler Rocker… ...

Signs show that babies can be taught simple hand gestures - St. Louis Post-Dispatch

Signs show that babies can be taught simple hand gestures
St. Louis Post-Dispatch,  United States -Jul 7, 2008
The program teaches babies, toddlers and young children to communicate using American Sign Language. This show reaches children by encouraging conversation ...

The Less-Stress Family Vacation - Reader's Digest

The Less-Stress Family Vacation
Reader's Digest, NY -Jul 7, 2008
There's also the issue of sand: Older, more mobile babies and toddlers who are prone to putting things in their mouths will be a challenge. ...


Giving babies space to grow - The Dominion Post

The Dominion Post

Giving babies space to grow
The Dominion Post, New Zealand -19 hours ago
Instead, a toddler who is very sure of his newly-learnt walk, greets us with a gummy smile and leads the way to a room with half a dozen mums and babies, ...